10 Best Drugstore Eye Creams for Dark Circles 2020

Are you frustrated by dark circles under your eyes and the high price of fancy eye cream brands? Don’t be – there’s plenty of (affordable) help right at your local drugstore.

To find the best drugstore eye cream for dark circles, you could purchase and try 10 different jars, but thanks to the help of our guide, you don’t have to waste your money trying a bunch of products.

Here in our guide, we highlight the top drugstore products to help those under eye circles disappear, so keep reading to find one that will work great for you!

What’s Causing Those Dark Circles?

The first step in tackling the annoying discoloration under your eyes is understanding what’s causing them. Many people don’t realize that there are several single or combined causes for the dark circles that they are experiencing.

For instance, did you know that one reason the circles look darker in the morning is that you have been lying flat all night? When you are horizontal, the veins in the area around your eyes expand and fluid accumulates in them causes the skin to darken.

Here’s a quick look at some other reasons:

  • Aging – This leads to loss of concealing fat, collagen, and elastin under the skin.
  • Lack of Sleep and Fatigue – We all know that pulling all-nighters does the skin under our eyes no favors whatsoever!
  • Dehydration – Consuming excess alcohol or caffeine or not drinking sufficient water dries out the skin.
  • Genetics – Quite often, dark circles around the eyes are an inherited (treatable) condition.
  • Fluid Build-Up – Blood pooling in capillaries just under the skin, for any reason, causes it to appear darker.

Top 10 Drugstore Eye Creams for Dark Circles Chart

PictureNameVolume (Ounces)Price Rating (1-5)
Volume (Ounces)
Rating (1-5)
1. Eye Cream with Hyaluronic Acid0.5-Ounce Jar$$$4.8
2. OZNaturals Eye Cream For Wrinkles1-Ounce Tube$$4.6
3. Retinol Cream Moisturizer for Face and Eyes1.7-Ounce Pump$$4.5
4. Eye Cream Moisturizer (1oz) 94% Natural Anti Aging Skin Care1.3-Ounce Pump$$4.4
5. Pure Biology “Total Eye” Anti Aging Eye Cream1-Ounce Pump$$$$4.4
6. Kiss Dark Circles & Eye Bags Goodbye! Organys Anti Aging Eye Cream0.5-Ounce Pump$$4.3
7. RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream Treatment0.5-Ounce Tube$4.1
8. Roc Multi Correxion 5 In 1 Eye Cream0.5-Ounce Tube$4.1
9. Beautifully Radiant's Antioxidant Eye Cream2-Ounce Pump$$4.1
10. CeraVe Eye Repair Cream 0.5 oz0.5-Ounce Tube$3.9

Selecting and Using Drugstore Eye Cream for Dark Circles

Not sure which cream to use? Here are a few tips to help you narrow down the options.

  • Be Careful If You Have Sensitive Skin or Allergies – Drugstore creams may be affordable, but their more affordable price tags can mean ingredients of lower quality.

If you have sensitive skin or allergies, be careful with drugstore brands and make sure you do the test patch before rubbing it under your eyes to avoid an allergic reaction.

  • Ingredients Are Key – Creams can’t work miracles on your eyes or skin, but they can contain ingredients that help reduce the appearance.

Check the label to see what the ingredients claim to do. Some may contain skin lightening ingredients while others may be tinted to help reduce the appearance while nourishing the skin from within, and brightening or illuminating serums are also great when it comes to reducing the appearance of dark circles.

Why Won’t Ordinary Face Creams Help?

The skin on your face isn’t the same all over. We all know that by the fact that ordinary face cream won’t effectively soothe lips – you need lip balm for that.

It is the same with the thin, sensitive skin around your eyes – it needs specially formulated eye cream.

What Are the General Rules for Applying Eye Cream?

Cold compresses are known to relieve the discoloration, so try leaving your eye cream in the refrigerator for a few hours. We suggest leaving it in overnight since you will want to apply it first thing in the morning when the dark circles are most pronounced.

When you apply the cream, begin at the inner corner of each eye and massage outwards with light sweeping motions. The gentle pressure will also help to drain lymph fluid in the area.

Even the very best product won’t give you instantly perfect results. So, after applying the eye cream, give your skin a few minutes to recover from the work, then apply a concealer of your choice to cover any lingering discoloration.

Top 3 Best Drugstore Eye Cream for Dark Circles Reviews

1. Stellar Skin Eye Cream

First off, we would like to point out that our one pet peeve with Stellar Skins eye cream is that it comes in a jar. You will have to take extra care using it to ensure you don’t contaminate the remaining contents.

In spite of that, we find it to be an incredibly effective product. It is 100% made in the U.S.A., it is cruelty-free, and it is paraben free – three very good-to-know facts.

The main ingredients are aloe vera and hyaluronic acid. Aloe vera is a soothing plant derivative known to have high levels of amino acids and minerals to nourish your skin. The hyaluronic acid your skin naturally contains but loses over time, is wonderfully hydrating, which helps to plump up and smooth the skin.

A couple of the other ingredients are glycerine to moisturize the skin and boost its healing capacity, as well as chamomile extract to relieve skin irritation naturally. Aside from the ingredients, we also like how well the skin absorbs the cream and that it does triple duty, helping to fight wrinkles and fine lines, as well.

2. OZNaturals Ultra Ageless

Coming in at a very close second in our search for the best drugstore eye cream for dark circles is OZNaturals Ultra Ageless. We were just as impressed with what’s in it as much as by what’s not.

It does not contain petrochemicals or emulsifiers, making it a good choice if you have sensitive skin. Also on this OZNaturals eye cream’s list of no-no’s are sulfates, fragrance, synthetic colors and sodium benzoate, to name a few.

The eye cream is made using a cold pressed method which the manufacturers say leaves the active ingredients with a higher degree of potency. Those active ingredients include astaxanthin (an anti-inflammatory seaweed derivative thought to promote skin health), matrixyl synthe’6 (an amino acid derivative frequently used in anti-wrinkle products).

Also in OZNaturals Ultra Ageless eye cream is antioxidant-rich carrot root and caffeine, whose revitalizing benefits we pointed out earlier. Along with the ingredients and manufacturing process, we like that this eye cream is sold in a convenient, easy-to-use tube.

3. LilyAna Naturals Retinol Cream

The LilyAna Naturals brand actually takes both third and fourth place on our list. Along with this Retinol eye cream, there is also a Rosehip and Hibiscus version for those who prefer to not use retinol.

That said, this LilyAna Naturals Retinol eye cream seems to have found a pretty good balance between the retinol and natural ingredients it contains. Here’s a rundown of what’s inside and what they’ll do for your skin.

First up, retinol is well-known for its anti-aging action on wrinkles and fine lines. It is also good at toning and repairing skin. Working with the retinol in this LilyAna Naturals eye cream are hyaluronic acid, jojoba oil, vitamin E, Shea butter and green tea.

The hyaluronic acid, as we already told you, is a good moisturizer. So too is the Shea butter which also has plenty of vitamins and fatty acids to nourish your skin. Both green tea and vitamin E will deliver rejuvenating anti-oxidant powers, while the jojoba oil, which is rich in vitamins A and E, will soothe your skin with its anti-inflammatory properties.

Apart from loving the ingredient profile, we feel reassured recommending LilyAna Naturals Retinol since it has no parabens or artificial fragrances and it was not tested on animals.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top