10 Best Drugstore Eye Makeup Removers 2018

It is almost painful to wipe away your carefully blended shadows and perfectly drawn eyeliner design at the end of the day (you worked so hard on it!), but your skin and sheets will thank you if you do.

There are plenty of great products out there to help you effectively remove all traces of makeup from your face, and some of the top products out there are available at your local drugstore.

Wondering which brands are worth a try and who formulates the best drugstore eye makeup remover?

Join us as we take a look at the most effective products that won’t drain your beauty budget.

Top 10 Drugstore Eye Makeup Removers Table

PictureNameTypePriceRating (1-5)
PictureNameTypePriceRating (1-5)
1. Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes & Wipes, Refill Pack, 25 CountWipes$$$$4.7
2. Olay Daily Facials Soap-Free Eye Makeup Remover and 4-In-1 Water Activated Facial Cleanser ClothsWipes$$4.5
3. Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water, Cleansing and Make-Up Removing Solution Liquid$$$4.4
4. Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, 5.5 Fl. Oz Oil-Free Liquid$4.4
5. Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water, For Waterproof Makeup, All Skin Types, 13.5 fl. oz. Oil-Free Liquid$4.3
6. La Roche-Posay Micellar Cleansing Water and Makeup Remover Oil-Free Liquid$4.2
7. Almay Longwear & Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover Pads, 120 Counts Pads$4.0
8. Simple Kind to Eyes Eye Makeup Remover Pads, 30 ct Pads$3.9
9. Maybelline Expert Eyes Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, For Washable Eye Makeup Oil-Free Liquid$3.9
10. Brooklyn Botany Camellia Wonder Oil - 100% Natural, 8.8 oz Oil$$3.8

What Is Micellar Water?

Micellar water seems to be all the rage with manufacturers and consumers these days, as products containing this unique product are popping up in many beauty blogs and skin care articles.

But what is it?

First, you need to understand what a micelle is – a cluster of surfactant molecules. Surfactants, as you may already know, are present in soaps and shampoos. They hels lower the surface tension between two liquids, allowing you to clean the dirt, grime, grease, and oil from your skin and hair.

Micelles are added to water for the same reason that other types of surfactants are added to soap and shampoo – to help loosen makeup and oil so it is easier to remove. They are gentler than the surfactants used in soap and shampoo, however, which is why you can use them without rinsing.

Wipes vs. Liquids

Are wipes more effective at removing eye makeup than liquids?

The answer is that it really depends on how much eye makeup you wear.

Many prefer towelettes and pads because they are more convenient. You can throw them in your purse or a carry on bag, and you don’t have to worry about spilling any product.

When it comes to removing heavy eye makeup or waterproof liners and mascara, however, liquids are more effective.

Products That Contain Oil

Many want to avoid products with oil because they think it will make their skin oilier, but this simply isn’t true!

Pure jojoba oil, for example, is a wonderful way to remove makeup naturally and nourishes the skin, but it does not cause your skin to produce more oil.

Ideally, a product that contains oil is used before you wash your face to help you remove the majority of eye makeup, and then you can wash your face to remove the rest.

If you wash first and then use an oily product, naturally your eyes will be oily, so just use it before washing, and you’ll be able to wash away any remaining oil when you cleanse.

Top 3 Best Drugstore Eye Makeup Remover Reviews

1. Neutrogena Makeup Remover 25 Count

Whether you’re on the go or at home, towelettes are some of the most convenient products for makeup removal.

One of the reasons why people love this product so much is that it removes waterproof mascara with ease yet the formula is gentle enough for sensitive eyes. If you wear contact lenses, this shouldn’t irritate you.

For light makeup, you can probably get away with using just one towelette, and for heavier makeup, two should do the job.

Even if you have both sensitive eyes and skin, this product seems to be gentle enough for most not to cause irritation or breakouts anywhere on the face.

Long time users swear by them, and we can’t deny that they are incredibly convenient. They do create more waste, however, which is probably the only reason we don’t like using them.

2. Olay Daily Facials Soap

The runner up is another brand of towelettes that work a bit differently than the previous product.

While Neutrogena’s towelettes come dampened, these cleansing cloths are packaged dry. They are water activated, so you simply run them under the faucet, wring them out, and then use.

They are textured to help you gently exfoliate the skin, and they work great on mascara and other eye makeup.

The point of this product is to cleanse your face rather than using a normal face wash. They’ve combined a toner, scrub, mask, and cleanser all into the formula so that you use fewer products in your cleaning routine.

We found it to be more effective at removing eye shadow than heavy liners and waterproof products, but if you use regular mascara and regualr liners, this should work fine.

3. Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water

Our final suggestion is one of those micellar waters that we were telling you about earlier.

As a gentle formula, this works very well on sensitive skin since it does not contain any parabens, fragrance or alcohol. As a water-based formula, it goes on light instead of greasy, but it also seems to require more product and more passes over the face for you to remove everything.

True, it isn’t the best drugstore eye makeup remover when it comes to mascara and eyeliner, but for eyeshadow and light foundation, it works well.

One of the reasons we suggested it is that it is such a friendly product to those with sensitive skin. It may take a bit more work for you to remove your eye makeup (you’ll use more cotton balls and Q-Tips), but at least it won’t burn them and cause your skin to break out.