10 Best Eye Makeup Removers for Sensitive Eyes 2018

It’s not easy shopping for cosmetics when you have sensitive skin, is it?

Nope, and it sure isn’t cheap, either.

You often find yourself shopping in the organic section and spending much more money than those who can get away with the cheaper, drugstore products, but with a little help from us, it doesn’t have to be that way.

In our list below, we’ll help you find the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes (because regular eyes can handle the harsh stuff better!) and help you understand what type of products you should be using.

We’ll top off our guide with reviews of our three favorite products and then leave you to the final choice!

Top 10 Eye Makeup Removers for Sensitive Eyes Table

PictureNameTypePriceRating (1-5)
PictureNameTypePriceRating (1-5)
1. Teak Naturals Organic Cold Pressed Unrefined Jojoba Oil, 4 oz.Carrier Oil$$$4.9
2. Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover,3.75 fl. oz. Eye Makeup Remover$$$4.6
3. Johnson's HEAD-TO-TOE Baby Wash, 28 Fl. Oz Wash$4.5
4. Klorane Floral Water Make-Up Remover With Soothing CornflowerEye Makeup Remover$$$$4.5
5. Premium Nature Makeup Remover Facial Cleanser - All Natural Gentle Wash Eye Makeup Remover$$4.5
6. Viva Naturals Sweet Almond Oil, Hexane Free for Skin and Hair, 16 oz / 473 mlCarrier Oil$$$4.5
7. Cetaphil Baby Wash and Shampoo with Organic Calendula, 7.8 Ounce Wash$4.4
8. LAVO #1 Best Organic Eye Makeup Remover Cleansing Oil - Deep Cleanser Cleanser$$$$4.3
9. The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover, 8.4 fl. oz. Eye Makeup Remover$$4.3
10. Earth Science Chamomile & Green Tea Eye Makeup Remover, 4fl.oz. Eye Makeup Remover$4.1

First and Foremost – DO the TEST PATCH

It doesn’t matter how many expert opinions you read or how many makeup gurus you seek answers from: we all have different skin, and we all have different reactions to skin care products.

The suggestions that we have for you here might be great for some people with sensitive eyes, but not for everyone.

Before you give any of these a try, make sure that you are NOT allergic to any of the ingredients or products by doing a test patch.

The best place to test a product is on the side of your neck: this is far enough away from the eyes not to irritate them but close enough to give you an idea of how your body will react.

Always try before you apply everywhere!

What You Can Use to Remove Eye Makeup (When You Have Sensitive Eyes)

Who says that the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes has to be marketed or labeled as such?

Sometimes the most effective products are intended for other uses, but just happen to double up as fabulous makeup removal products.

  • Jojoba Oil. We know that some carrier oils require a higher investment up front, but they do last much longer than any of the specialty products you’ll find, and they are also more versatile. It’s not like you need the highest quality of jojoba oil out there, either; just choose a bottle of the cheaper kind (and by cheaper that doesn’t mean it will automatically be lower in quality) and one that has a dropper so that you avoid wasting product.

Just a few drops on a cotton swab or cotton disc and you’re on your way to makeup-free eyes minus the irritation.

  • Natural, Tear-Free Soap. Tear-free soap that is also free of all of the junk (sulfates, parabens, harsh chemicals, etc.) is a great way to get rid of heavy eye makeup when you’re still washing your face.

What you need to understand is that soap you use to remove eye makeup shouldn’t be spread all over your face since it might cause the rest of your skin to break out. Just put a small drop on your fingers, lather it up, close your eyes and gently wash off the makeup. Rinse and then proceed as normal with your face cleansing routine!

  • Sweet Almond Oil. Make sure that you opt for sweet almond oil that is unscented, as the scented oil is just too strong and might end up irritating your eyes.

It is an alternative to jojoba oil and can also help you remove traces of foundation and other makeup from the skin’s surface.

There are other products out there specifically designed for removing eye makeup that might work for you, so if you find that these natural solutions don’t do the trick, try the others.

What You Should Avoid

Some products are just born to irritate sensitive eyes, so if you see the following ingredients on the product label, it is best to avoid them completely: they are known skin irritants.

  • Fragrance
  • Alcohol
  • Some Essential Oils
  • Products with Citrus
  • Witch Hazel

If you use these around the eyes, chances are they will irritate them. Again, we recommend that you always do the test patch to make sure a product is safe!

Top 3 Best Eye Makeup Remover for Sensitive Eyes

1. Teak Naturals Organic Cold Pressed

Jojoba oil makes an excellent makeup remover because it doesn’t have a strong scent and it isn’t a known skin irritant. In fact, it is quite the opposite.

Jojoba oil is non-allergenic, non-comedogenic it is moisturizing and helps nourish the lashes. Just one application of this oil to the eyes and you’re not only removing makeup but nourishing everything you touch in the process!

We chose this particular brand because it has a) a dropper and b) it wasn’t as expensive as some of the therapeutic grade oils.

This is the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes for many who try it, but we can’t guarantee that it will work for you. If jojoba oil doesn’t work for you, check out the next few solutions.

2. Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

Mary Kay’s oil-free eye makeup remover seems to be a hit with many users, including those with sensitive skin.

The formula is free of fragrance and non-comedogenic, two things that we like to hear when it comes to a product that we are using near the eyes.

It is both a gentle and effective product: if you wash and dry your face but still find that there are traces of eye makeup under your eyes or along the lash line, just dampen a cotton swab with a little liquid to gently remove it.

True, it is a bit more expensive than some of the other options, but it works very well.

3. Johnson’s HEAD-TO-TOE Baby Wash

For waterproof makeup and heavy black eyeliner, you should probably use a gentle wash to help you remove the majority of the product before you use a carrier oil or eye makeup remover to help you remove what’s left.

This particular wash is intended for babies, and since it is such a gentle, tear-free formula, you can also try it on your eyes, as well.

While it isn’t the most natural wash on our list, it is gentle and doesn’t seem to create too many problems for those with slightly sensitive skin. If you have super sensitive skin, then avoid this one: the rest of you can probably get away with using a small amount to wash your eyes and then rinsing away the suds before you continue with your regular cleansing routine.