best smudge proof mascara

15 Best Smudge Proof Mascaras That Won’t Break or Flake

If you have the chance to take frequent breaks during the day in order to touch up your makeup, chances are that you’ve probably had to deal with a mascara issue or two.

Smudging is one of many problems that your mascara can cause you, which is why we’ll be looking at some of the best smudge-proof mascara options on our list below.

Before we get started, however, you should know that the waterproof mascara may not always be the right answer, and here’s why…

Smudge-Proof vs. Waterproof

Most of us probably assume that waterproof is going to be the best smudge-proof mascara and for some of you, it probably is!

  • Resisting Water. When water is involved, then most likely a waterproof mascara is going to prevent you from experiencing any smudging problems. A dip in the pool, a quick shower when you get off work, and need to freshen up before your dinner date when you’re crying at a wedding. Waterproof is your friend!


  • Resisting Oil and Humidity. When you have super oily skin or live in particularly humid areas, this is where waterproof mascara doesn’t always work.


Mascaras that are marketed as smudge-proof aren’t always waterproof, which means that you won’t experience any issues when oil and humidity are involved, but you can experience problems if your eyes are (swimming, shower, tears, etc.)

You also have products that are designed to be both water and smudging!

What Else Do You Want Your Mascara To Do?

Now that you’ve determined that you want something smudge-proof, waterproof, or both, next you need to choose what kind of look you need.

  • More volume?
  • Longer lashes?
  • Easier to remove?
  • Good for sensitive skin?

Think about what you want the mascara to do for your eyes once it’s applied to help you narrow down the choices.

Don’t forget about the color! Black and brown aren’t the only choices out there. You might want to mix it up a little by adding in a fun, bold color.

Prep Your Lashes

An important part of experiencing a smudge-free look is the prep work you do.

  • Curling. Make sure you have an eyelash curler that is appropriate for your eye shape and your lashes.

If you have stick-straight lashes, you might look into using a heated eyelash curler. For short eyelashes, try using a mini clamp curler in order to curl small sections at a time.

One of the biggest mistakes people make when curling is doing so after they apply mascara. Some of you may do this and it works fine, but we highly suggest that you curl before. You risk breaking off eyelashes since the mascara will stick to the curler when you open it. Ouch!

  • Primer. Primers will help nourish your lashes and give the mascara something to adhere to once you apply it, so after you’ve curled, apply a light coat of primer to prep your lashes. Break up any clumps with an eyelash brush and then proceed with mascara as normal.

This can also help thicken the lashes for those of you who have very thin, fine lash hair follicles.

Fiber Mascara

You’ll notice that we have a few fiber lash mascara options, and if you’re new to the makeup world, you might not have heard of this.

Basically, this mascara leaves little fibers on your eyelashes as you apply it with the wand, allowing you to slowly build and lengthen them.

It’s true that many mascaras do this anyways, but products marketed as “fiber mascaras” usually come with two tubes: the gel in one and the fibers in the other.

For those who want length without using false eyelashes, this might be the perfect product for you!

Best Smudge-Proof Mascara

best smudge proof mascara

As we just mentioned, a fiber mascara might be the right choice for you if you’re looking for serious lengthening power and smudge-proof, like this one. You’ll get the gel and the fiber plus an extra brush to help you separate any clumps. The result also seems to outperform the unique brand which costs way more!

Another less expensive alternative is smudge-proof mascara that will satisfy you with an amazing finish! It claims to be a water-resistant product rather than waterproof. But since you’re on the hunt for smudge-proof, we can confirm that it is exactly that! It won’t clump and smudge. Perfect for those with short lashes.

If you’re in need of a bit of volume but not necessarily length, then you might try the CoverGirl LashBlast Volume mascara. This is not waterproof but it stays on your lashes and won’t smudge. It is also an excellent alternative if you’re not looking for volume.

Fiber mascara is popular because of its quality which provides nearly perfect results, and this Lagure 400X Silk Fiber Lash Mascara is one of the best smudge-proof mascaras to try! Its set-improved formula will effortlessly lift up, volumize, and lengthen your lashes, giving you an elegant look. It is also hypoallergenic, thus, working great for sensitive eyes.

Do you wish to have a bold statement for your lashes? Choose no further than CoverGirl Professional Remarkable Smudge-Proof Mascara! It has an intense black color that will definitely make your lashes stand out. Thanks to its lightweight build-up formula, your lashes won’t clump, smudge, or feel heavy while you wearing the mascara.

Despite being a waterproof and smudge-proof mascara, this Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Waterproof Mascara won’t make you struggle with dry lashes. Thanks to the vitamin E formula, it keeps your lashes nourished and hydrated, thus preventing lash loss. It also offers you natural, healthy-looking, long lashes anyone dreams of.

Whether you want to create a sensational or natural look, Bobbi Brown No Smudge Mascara will grant your wish in one go! The buildable formula gives a voluminous, long, curly effect to your lashes without clumping, smudging, and smearing. It also comes with a patented brush that helps you coat every single lash perfectly.

As its name suggests, you will get an extensive, voluminous look once you apply this mascara to your lashes. Its natural carnauba and beeswax ingredients blend beautifully with a lightweight formula, staying put on your curly lashes all day. If you use eyelash extension, this product will be your life savior to make the lashes more on point.

Estée Lauder says out loud when it comes to smudge-proof mascara. It highlights smudge-shield formula with innovative polymers that prevent high humidity and temperature smudging. Plus, its bristles feature microfibers that can fully cover the lashes from the roots to the tips, displaying long lashes lasting for 15 hours.

There is nothing wrong with a curvy brush to create voluminous, curly, fuller-looking lashes. It helps you separate and coats the lashes with its rich formula and intense glossy color for bold statement lashes. In addition, panthenol, licorice root, and peach leaf extract ensure your lashes stay hydrated and well-nourished with no smudge.

Despite having a mini size, your result after applying this mascara will be BANG! – just like its name. It is because of the effect that gives the impression of bigger and fuller-looking lashes but lightweight-wearing, thanks to its aero-particle and smudge-proof formula. Those who favor voluminous lashes will definitely love this piece!

Say bye-bye to raccoon eyes! This Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara has a smudge-proof and waterproof formula that won’t budge for up to 24 hours, offering a long-lasting, no flaky look. It also bears a wavy fiber brush that allows you to easily glides on your lashes, layering each lash beautifully with rich ingredients.

Why do you need fake lashes with sticky glue if you have this mascara? This is the best smudge-proof mascara that provides a voluminous lash-lifting effect in just one swipe. With its humidity-resistant formula, it guarantees no-run and no-smear mascara. Whether you want to create doll eyes or wing eyes, it is not an issue if you apply this one.

Have no time to do proper lashes? Try this Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Mascara from Bareminerals Maximist! It comes with an orange peel cellulose ingredient that offers instant lifting and volumizing lashes for a maximum look but without smudging. Not to mention the micro-algae complex that will keep your lashes healthy and thick.

Tarte releases a Tarte Mini SEA Surfer Curl Volumizing Mascara that you can rely on when you are on the trip since it is travel-size. It gives a natural lash-lifting finish that won’t be overly dramatic. The algae extract, and vitamin E are also beautifully combined as excellent antioxidant properties in this product.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

How do I stop my mascara smudging?

You can try to apply foundation or concealer to bake your eyelids before using your mascara to prevent smudging. 


Besides, setting powder and setting spray may also help you tackle this issue, just in case you don’t have a foundation or concealer

Does waterproof mascara prevent smudging?

Waterproof mascara does well for a long-lasting look all-day even though being exposed to water, rain, tears, and sweat. However, it is not the case when the mascara meets oil skin. Unfortunately, it will still smear and smudge. 


With that being said, waterproof mascara doesn’t mean smudge-proof too. It is better to choose the best smudge-proof mascara if you wish to have an outstanding look with no raccoon eyes from smudging.

Why does my mascara keep smudging under my eyes?

Actually, it is not your mascara that can cause this problem, but your oily eyelids. Smudge mascara is often experienced by those who have oily skin. 


However, you can try the baking technique using foundation, concealer, or setting powder. They help reduce oils on the skin that causes your mascara to smear or run.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top