10 Best Drugstore Under Eye Concealers 2018

Finding quality concealers without paying department store prices is easy if you know where to look.

Luckily for you, we’ve done all the looking for you and in order to help you find the best drugstore under eye concealer, we won’t even require you to make a trip to the drugstore.

You’ll find everything you need below along with some useful shopping and application tips, so be sure to read them all!

What Don’t You Like About Your Current Concealer

In order to find your new favorite concealer, think about what your current one isn’t offering you and make a checklist so you can narrow down the choices.

  • Consistency. Here we are referring to the consistency of the concealer material itself. Are you using a solid (sticks, pencils) or cream?

If the stick is the problem, try switching to a cream, or vice versa. Usually the ones with a wand are thinner than the creams in the tubes, so if you need something for brightening, get one with a thinner consistency.

  • Skin Irritation Issues. Many of us do not always associate our skin problems with the brand of makeup we use the very first time we see a symptom. That’s because it could be due to many different factors!

If you’ve determined that your red, itchy eyes have occurred when using any eye-related products (concealer included), then it might be time for a brand switch.

  • Color Is Off. Some brands offer way more color selections than others, so if you have a middle-of-the-road skin tone, try switching to a brand that offers you more color selection in order to find the perfect match.
  • It’s for Blemishes. If you’re trying to use a spot/blemish concealer under your eyes, then there is the problem right there.

For creating a flawless look under the eye, you need a concealer that is specifically designed for this area of your face. This is what we’ll help you find on our table below, so scroll down and have a look!

Top 10 Drugstore Under Eye Concealers Comparison

PictureName# of ShadesPriceRating (1-5)
PictureName# of ShadesPriceRating (1-5)
1. Neutrogena 3-in-1 Concealer For Eyes4$$4.5
2. Maybelline New York Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circles Treatment Concealer6$4.4
3. Revlon Photoready Concealer6$4.3
4. CoverGirl Smoothers Concealer4$4.3
5. Maybelline New York Fit Me! Concealer6$4.2
6. e.l.f. Under Eye Concealer and Highlighter, Glow Light3$4.3
7. COVERGIRL Trublend Fixstick Concealer Light L5-76$4.2
8. Rimmel Wake Me Up Concealer4$$4.0
9. L'Oreal Paris Visible Lift CC Eye Concealer3$$4.0
10 NYX Cosmetics Concealer Jar12$$$3.8

Allow the Color Wheel to Help You

Your search for the best drugstore under eye concealer has probably lead you to a lot of videos, tutorials and product demos. They’re all great resources when it comes to choosing a product.

What we also want you to remember is that it shouldn’t be about the product only but also the color.

Take a look at the dark circles under your eyes and you’ll notice that they have a bluish/grey pigmentation. Looking on the opposite side of the color wheel, you’ll find that orangey/yellow tones are directly across from these.

Applying more of an orange or yellow-tinted concealer will help you neutralize the dark color and prevent it from showing up once you set everything on your face with a powder.
pic1pic2

There are plenty of hues of orange out there, so we’re not saying that you need something that is like your Halloween pumpkin, but use it as a starting point.

We highly recommend that you check out the NYX Cosmetics Concealer Jar concealer (number 10) if you have really dark, highly contrasting spots and circles on your skin.

They have 12 different colors to choose from, so you can get a jar of this to help you with your problem areas and then proceed with your favorite concealer as you blend and/or highlight.

If You Don’t Use Foundation

Some of you might not use a foundation every time you put some makeup on, so if that’s the case, it’s extra important for you to find a color as close to your natural skin tone as possible.

Be careful, however, if you need to cover dark circles.

Again, it’s best to get a color that will lighten the circles and bring them closer to your natural skin tone so that you can finish off with a regular concealer.

Blend everything well and set with a light powder in order to make your look natural!

5 Best Drugstore Under Eye Concealer Reviews

1. Neutrogena 3-in-1 Concealer

If you’re looking for a concealer that will also help moisturize the skin under your eyes, this is an excellent product.

Type: Cream
Shades:

pic3

From left to right: Fair, Buff, Light, Medium

It blends and covers well, brightens the area under your eyes and gives you a smooth look. Not too heavy when you put it on and it won’t enhance wrinkles (thank you moisturizer).

Yes, this is an excellent product, but if you’ve already tried it and didn’t like, check out the next one.

2. Maybelline New York Instant Age Rewind Eraser

This is probably the best drugstore concealer for dark circles on our list. We know that tackling the dark circles requires a few extra steps for some of you, but in general, this does an excellent job.

Type: Cream
Shades:

pic4

We like that it comes in six colors so that you have more of a choice, plus the sponge applicator at the end of the tube really helps you cover those dark circles as you apply and then blend.

If you have oily skin and you’re afraid that the moisturizer/concealer combo will melt right off your face, we still have a few more products for you to check out so keep reading!

3. Revlon Photoready Concealer

If you’re looking for an all-purpose concealer stick that you’ll use mainly under the eyes and to cover a few spots around your face, Revlon’s PhotoReady concealer is pretty good.

Type: Stick
Shades:

pic5

From left to right: Fair, Light, Light Medium, Medium, Medium Deep, Deep

Again, you get the six colors, so if you didn’t like the previous one because it’s creamy, this is an alternative.

It works best on those of you who need light coverage (not for super dark under eye circles) and have red areas that you’re trying to tackle (remember that a bit of green concealer will also help!). It definitely brightens and covers, so if that’s what you’re looking for in a concealer, then it might be the perfect fit!

4. CoverGirl Smoothers Concealer

CoverGirl has been a classic drugstore favorite for decades, and they’re still going strong in the concealer department today!

Type: Stick
Shades:

pic6

From left to right: Neutralizer, Fair, Deep, Medium, Illuminator, Light

This is a long lasting concealer that blends well and looks natural if you find the right pigmentation for your skin tone. Some find that it does tend to settle in the creases, but that might also depend on what you put on your skin prior to using the concealer.

Another great option if you’re looking for something new!

5. Maybelline New York Fit Me! Concealer

Maybelline tops our list again with their Fit Me! concealer, which works really well if you’re looking for something that will highlight or for mild circles under the eyes.  

Type: Cream
Shades:

pic7

As we mentioned, it would be great to use a product like number 10 together with this one if you have dark circles.

You’ll want to counteract the dark color with an orangey/peachy color (which you’ll find with number 10) and then you can follow up for some highlighting with a product like this.

If you have very mild darkness under your eyes, then this product alone will work fine if you find the right color match for your skin tone!