15 Best Eye Primers for Oily Lids

We can understand that sometimes applying eye makeup can be very frustrating, especially if the makeup slides off your face two hours after it’s applied. Putting a makeup to your eyes is indeed a bit tricky, and it’s even more so for those of you who have oily lids. You’ll need extra efforts to make your eye makeup on point all day, which is why putting an eye primer for oily lids is recommended. 

If you’ve been searching here and there for the best eye primers for your oily lids, first you need to understand why there is oil in your eyelids. As a result, you’ll have better understanding on how to prep your eyes appropriately and you will also know exactly what kind of eye primer that can perfectly enhance your eye makeup.

Why Some Eyelids Can be so Oily?

There are many factors that contribute to oily eyelids. Therefore, before you just assume that all of the oil is accumulating on your lids, here are a few reasons on why such condition could happen in the first place:

  • You’re Using Creams

Oil and some creams just don’t mix. So if you’re using a cream shadow, then it could possibly be the culprit of the problem. Therefore, try switching to dry and powder shadows instead.

It’s also possible that the eye cream you’ve been using around your eyelid has increased the oil production. So use it less frequently to see if that makes a difference.

  • You Might Have an Allergy

Whether it’s to the pollen floating around in the air or to a product you’re using near your face, we all know how allergies can really affect the eyes.

If your oily problem has recently developed, think about any changes in the air, your environment, or the facial products that you’ve been using. Moreover, rubbing your eyes frequently will also increase oil production.

  • Hormones

Yes, hormones can also affect the amount of oil that your skin produces, which applies on both the eyes and face. Moreover, it is also possible that you developed oily skin due to genetics reasons.

  • Type of Moisturizers and Cleansers You Use

It’s all about the base! Your skin care routine and products greatly affect, well, basically everything you do after they are applied. The wrong product on your skin will dry it out and therefore increase oil production, so it might be the right time to re-think and also change your moisturizers and cleansers.

  • You don’t Use Primers

As the beauty guru Nikkie Tutorials always say, no prime is a crime. If you’re wondering why, it’s because primers play such an important role in your daily makeup. Whether it is for your eyes only or your entire face. 

Hence, choosing the right eye primer is the right action to take, especially after you understand the reasons as to why your lids appear to be oily and not makeup friendly.

Top 15 Best Eye Primer for Oily Lids

As you can see from our tips above, there are a lot of factors that can affect the skin on your eyelids (as well as the rest of your face), so keep this in mind as you search for the best eye primer for your oily lids.

Your bad experience with a certain brand of primer may not be due to the product being poor. But, in fact, it may also caused by some other factors that you’re not aware of. Therefore, to help you find the best eye primer for oily lids, we already generated a list of the best options you can get down below.

best eye primer for oily lids

1. Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Primer

This is a PETA-registered product, so if you like the idea of purchasing products that weren’t tested on animals and that happen to work wonders on oily lids, this one comes as a favorite for many people who love to wear makeup.

A little goes a long way and it’s long lasting. Definitely our fave!

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

2. Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

This one is actually quite pricey for a 0,33 oz eye primer. However, it also happens to be one of the best eye primers for oily lids that you can easily find in the market.

Urban Decay is an “OMG this stuff is amazing!” type product, and if you’re willing to fork over the money, chances are you will find yourself in eyelid heaven and never go back to the other brands.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids


Many people with oily lids have had a lot of luck with this NYX’s eyeshadow primer formula. Because of its smooth satin texture, it will definitely work well as a base on metallic and also on other shimmery shadows. 

This primer is so good that it can make your lids look smoother, which ensures a more flawless eye makeup look with less creasing.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

4. Wet n Wild Fergie Centerstage Collection Take On The Day Eyeshadow Primer

Wet n Wild is very popular among those who are searching for good quality makeup products that are relatively cheap. Their Take on The Day Eyeshadow Primer is proved working best when it comes to prevent creasing on oily lids. You only need a bit of this primer to cover the entire lids, and it will hold the eye makeup so well that it became a rival to more high-end brands.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

5. Too Faced Cosmetics, Shadow Insurance

This primer is enriched with vitamin E. So it doesn’t only do its job to lock down your eye shadow colors, but also cares for your skin and keeps your lids extra healthy. 

In addition, it also has full-coverage insurance policy against all fading, creasing, melting, blurring, oil slicked and also hard-to-blend eye-shadow accidents. Furthermore, the skin soothing formula also evens out the skin tone on your lids and smoothes out lines while also secures a barrier between the oils of your skin and your makeup.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

6. e.l.f. Shadow Lock Eyelid Primer

This lightweight formula preps eyes for eyeshadow application to increase staying power, color vibrancy, and also to avoid creasing throughout the day. This formula allows you to apply eyeshadow in the morning and have it maintain its freshly-added look all day. Better of all, this product is 100% vegan and cruelty free.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

7. Smashbox 24 Hour Photo Finish Eyeshadow Primer

This 24 Hour Photo Finish Shadow Primer keeps your eyeshadow in place and vibrant for 24 hours or until you take it off. It forms a smooth base onto lids that makes applying powder or cream shadows an ease.

Moreover, the sweat and humidity resistant formula also helps to prevent budging, fading, and also creasing even on extreme oily lids. You can definitely trust your eye makeup look on this primer.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

8. Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Pro Filt’r Amplifying Eye Primer

This next item is a weightless and color-boosting eyeshadow primer that keeps your eye makeup on top of its game. It smooths the lids for easier blending and longer crease-proof wear. This is hands-down the best and longest-lasting eye primer for oily lids. 

In addition, the eyeshadow also stays put all day and it is safe for sensitive skin, so this one is definitely an A plus.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

9. Anastasia Beverly Hills Mini Eye Primer

So many people love this primer that they are asking for the full size. But we all know that ABH can be quite pricey and getting the minis will actually salvage us from spending too much. 

Simply have a tiny drop of this primer to get your eyelids ready. The formula has a dry finish so it will definitely keep your eye makeup fresh and stay all day, even on bad days when you have such oily lids.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

10. NARS Pro-Prime™ Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base

A lightweight primer that creates a seamless canvas that keeps cream and powder eye color looking brilliant and fresh. This formula helps you to get a firm grip on color for long-lasting and also gorgeous wear. 

Moreover, it is also enriched with antioxidants, which perform well on oily lids. Therefore, this one is considered as a game changer.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

11. ULTA Matte Eye Primer

This one will come as a great primer , especially if you intend to wear it under pigmented eyeshadows and also to prevent oiliness. It dries down in nude matte finish and is also not translucent, so you may need to keep that in mind. 

Just use a little bit of this product to get a smooth blank canvas that you’re aiming for. Undoubtedly, it will keep the shadows stay all day and not crease.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

12. Benefit Cosmetics Stay Don’t Stray Eyeshadow Primer

An excellent eyeshadow primer that also works as a concealer. It will definitely help you to even out discoloration, which will get your eye makeup stays for a long time. 

However, since the formula is a little bit thick, you only need to use a little bit of it. Otherwise, you will get your eyelids feeling heavy and may even crack the eye makeup. In short, this is a great primer for no makeup makeup days.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

13. Juvia’s Place I Prep, I Prime

Juvia’s Place I Prep I Prime Eyeshadow Primers helps in creating a weightless and also seamless base for eyeshadow applications. It cancels out pigmentation or discoloration, plus it also intensifies colors and prevents creas and oiliness, too.

However, the formula is a little watery so you need to be careful when using it, and you need to wait until it dries down completely before applying your shadows.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

14. Morphe Eyelid Primer

This eyelid primer has a dry and matte finish, making it a perfect eyelid primer for oily skin. It dries down quite fast so you need to hurry when applying it to get a smooth blend. In addition, this primer has a waterproof formula so you can wear it worry free for up to 12 hours. Truly a great primer for everyday use.

buy here

best eye primer for oily lids

15. MAC Prep + Prime 24-Hour Extend Eye Base

Anyone who suffers from oily lids definitely needs to get this primer. It helps eyeshadow stay color-true and prevents it from fading and creasing. Not only great for the eyeshadows, this primer also works wonderfully for the eyeliner as well. 

So it’ s time say goodbye to smudged liners that make you look tired, and say hello to the vibrant color eyeshadows and snatched liners all day.

buy here

Which eye primer is the best for oily lids?

Trial and error, friends! It’s basically about weeding out the products that don’t agree with your skin. Every skin has different requisites, which needs different treatments, too. Some people swear by the above products while others find that those products do basically nothing to their oily lids problem. Eventually, you need to try one by one until you find the one that works best for you.

Is primer good for oily skin?

Yes, definitely. In fact, some primers are actually formulated to help you to deal with the oiliness of your eyelids. These primers have a formula to create a layer that separates the shadow from the skin. They also protect the shadows from oils that may occur and keep it stay longer as well. However, you need to be more careful if you naturally have sensitive skin.

Is eye primer the same as face primer?

They are basically similar but not exactly the same. Both contain water and silicone to fill up pores and also lines. They also cover the skin and make it smooth to touch. Eye primer however, has a slightly different formulation that makes it last longer and tackier, so in terms of texture, it allows eyeshadow color to stick better.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *