One of the most popular drugstore brands on the planet is the one and only Maybelline New York. From great foundations to sexy shadows, their product range has something for every budget. Their mascaras for instance. Maybelline mascaras are particularly popular, and we probably already know some options of the best Maybelline mascara on the market. But which ones stand out above the rest? What’s the difference between each product – aside from the wand shape – and what to know about the formulas?
You can find the answers to those questions here in our guide, where we highlight the best Maybelline mascara that the brand has to offer. We will also share some of our shopping secrets to help you choose the right one for your lashes.
Contents
Maybelline’s Top Mascara Lines
Does Maybelline just put the same product in a different tube, change the wand, and change the packaging? The answer is no, they do not. In order to be sure about it, we have checked the validity of those facts.
The ingredients are vary even between products that come from the same line of product. Still, to help make it easier for the consumer to choose the best one, they group similar products on each line to help you better navigate the mascaras that will deliver your desired result.
- Volum’ Express. You’ll find products that offer 9X or 12X the volume in this line. Some of the wands in this line make it easier to apply a thicker product coating in one stroke. But if you don’t want to layer, then you could try something like Volum’ Express The Colossal.
- Great Lash. Maybelline’s Great Lash mascara has been a favorite for over 40 years and is still strong today. Their original formula, which is the Great Lash Curved, is one of the most popular products in this line. They have been receiving high praise from magazines, readers, makeup junkies, and everyone in between. There are a few different options, each with a different wand and a slightly different formula, including a waterproof version, just in case you don’t want the washable kind.
- Full ‘N Soft. There are only two products in this line – the washable and waterproof versions. We found the washable mascara to perform slightly better than the waterproof, but you may love the waterproof formula as well.
- Lash Sensational. These mascaras are designed to give your lashes the full fan effect. Since your lashes consist of various layers, the wand in these products will help you apply the product to all of them. The result is more volume from root to tip.
- Lash Stiletto. Check out their Stiletto products if you have short and stubby lashes. Like the Full ‘N Soft, this line comes in both the washable and waterproof versions. However, the waterproof formula wasn’t up to par.
What’s up with the Wands?
The best Maybelline mascara varies from user to user because all of us have different lashes. Some people have straight and thick lashes, while others have slightly curved and thin lashes. The combinations are countless!
When you understand what type of wand shape will help your lashes to pop, then shopping for mascara will be so much easier to be done.
- Curved. The curved wand will help to add a bit of curl to your lashes. If you have stick-straight lashes, then you will still need an eyelash curler’s help to achieve a lasting curl, but if you just want to define your lashes and add a bit of curl, then you can go with the curved wand.
- Straight. A straight wand will do the trick for general use without any lash powers. Remember that those with thin bristles will apply the product more heavily, helping add volume to particularly thin lashes. Wands with thicker bristles will also help add volume, but they also help you apply the product to lashes individually, and you can increase the volume by building up the product.
- Tapered. The tapered wand is very handy if you have a tough time coating all lashes, starting from the inner corner to the outer corner of your eyes. The smaller end helps you reach lashes in the outer regions and along the bottom line, while the thicker end helps you in adding more oomph to the middle of your top line.
Top 15 Best Maybelline Mascaras
After knowing the ultimate tips and tricks on mascara shopping, now let’s dive into the best Maybelline mascaras that you can find for your specific lash needs.
1. Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara
If you want to elongate, separate, and flare out your lashes, then you may want to give this bad boy a try. It stays all day and adds the volume dramatically, especially when you have a full-day even outdoors. This mascara features an innovative fanning curved brush that shapes, stretches and reveals layers of lashes for a curvy full fan effect. In terms of price, it is fairly affordable and also ophthalmologist tested, making it a suitable product for contact lens wearers.
Pros:
- Adds volume
- Hypoallergenic
- Suitable for contact lens wearers
Cons:
- Can be a little hard to take off so you need a really good eye makeup remover
2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
The difference between this mascara and the previous product is the wand. The previous one has a curl brush, while this one has a straight brush that can bend to volumize and extend every single lash from root to tip. If you want to have longer looking lashes, then you can definitely opt for this one. It stays all day and buildable so you can always add some more for a more dramatic night look. However, this one is a little bit pricier than the previous product, but it does a really good job in adding length to your lashes.
Pros:
- Bendable wand to coat every single lashes
- Add length
- Buildable
Cons:
- The washable version doesn’t contains carmine, so keep in mind if you have allergies towards carmines
3. Maybelline Waterproof Falsies Lash Lift Mascara
Achieve length, volume and lash lift effect with this fiber-infused formula that thickens and extends your lashes. The unique flexible wand helps to lift and separate, which will be providing you with a fuller looking lashes. The patented spoon brush and Kera-Fiber formula also builds 8X more volume to achieve The Falsies lash effect. In short, this one is quite affordable for a mascara that delivers such dramatic results.
Pros:
- Ophthalmologist tested
- Suitable for contact lens wearers
- Hold curls
Cons:
- A little hard to get off your lashes, so you need to carefully remove it with high-quality eye makeup remover
4. Maybelline Volum’ Express Colossal Curl Bounce Mascara
This washable mascara delivers lasting bouncy lashes as well as defies clumps, smudges, and flakes. Its memory curl formula gives 24 hours long wear for maximum appearance. The brush also separates, coats, and curls up every lash, which gives you a more natural beautiful lashes. Even better, it is easy to use and fairly easy to remove with makeup remover as well. On price pint of view, it is quite affordable for a mascara that can do just so much.
Pros:
- Easy to use
- Long wearing
- Can be easily removed
Cons:
- Not hypoallergenic
5. Maybelline Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Waterproof Mascara
Try the Stiletto ultimate length mascara if you want to instantly build 70% longer-looking lashes with luminous shine for a dramatic wide-eye look. The best part about this mascara is that it does not only serve the look, but it also conditions and nourishes your lashes with its pro vitamin B5 formula. In summary, this product is very affordable for a mascara that can give you longer lashes while keeping them healthy.
Pros:
- Nourishing
- Applies evenly
- Great brush
Cons:
- Dries out to quickly and a little bit hard to remove
6. Maybelline The Falsies Waterproof Mascara
This one is the mascara that can do it all. It will give you both length and volume, or you can just brush them once or twice for less volume or length. It can also build up some more of both volume and length for maximum dramatic effect. You’ll definitely love this mascara, because it does not clump unless you overdo it by overlapping too many layers. Other than that, it can make your lashes look like false lashes and you will get compliments for your fuller looking lashes. Very affordable for its capability.
Pros:
- Add length and volume
- Buildable
- Doesn’t leave black residue under your eyes
Cons:
- It’s not a 24 hour stay on product, but can hold long enough for a day out
7. Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara
If taking off your makeup quickly is your ultimate goal, then you can always opt for a washable mascara. You can wipe off this mascara effortlessly to save time and energy, especially at night after a long day of various activities. Moreover, it also gives the result you want as it makes your mascara appear darker and show up great, even when you’re wearing eyeglasses. In terms of price, it is very affordable and it also suitable for makeup wearers at any age.
Pros:
- Easy to take off
- Clump free
- Doesn’t flake
Cons:
- May need several coats to get the desired coverage
8. Maybelline The Colossal Washable Mascara
You will love the way this product leaves your lashes dark and longer, especially the fact that the mascara is washable and easy to remove, too. It doesn’t feel heavy on your lashes, therefore you can definitely wear it daily. This mascara comes with a specifically designed mega brush that instantly achieves 9x the volume without clumps. Furthermore, it also fairly affordable for a mascara that contains volume plumping formula with collagen.
Pros:
- Easy to remove
- Contains collagen
- Clump free
Cons:
- Can be flaky on hot weather
9. Maybelline Lash Discovery Mini-Brush Waterproof Mascara
The brush that comes with this mascara works like magic, as it is able to find the teeniest lash and separates them evenly. The formula is nicely buildable, and you can even use it as a primer before putting on your other mascara. It makes your lashes appear longer and fuller without any clump, and it works wonderfully on the lower lashes as well. With this affordable mascara, you can definitely get the desired beautiful lashes that look better than falsies.
Pros:
- Easy to apply
- Buildable formula
- Small brush that can get the tiniest lashes
Cons:
- The product can be easily dry out if you don’t close it properly after use
10. Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Waterproof Mascara
A very affordable mascara that will help lengthen your eyelashes while adding fullness. It is easy to apply and you can add layers to make a more dramatic without looking clumpy. And as the name suggests, it is super soft to the lashes and totally safe to wear, even for sensitive eyes. Moreover, the waterproof formula passes the test of time and can even stand in the water.
Pros:
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
- No smudging or clumping
- Hold curls
Cons:
- It has a natural finish so if you expect a dramatic volume, you may choose the other products instead
11. Maybelline New York Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara
In this product, the fiber fix brush and fiber extensions formula work together to achieve dramatically longer lashes. The Fiber-fix brush reaches each lash from different angles for optimal fiber placement. Also, the sealing formula visibly stretches lashes and seals the fibers securely to each lash without flaking or breaking. Moreover, it won’t break your pocket as well, because it is fairly affordable and safe for contact lens wearers.
Pros:
- Easy to apply
- No smudge or clump
- Suitable for contact lens wearers
Cons:
- Light coverage and focus on lengthen the lashes, not volume
12. Maybelline Define-A-Lash Mascara
The silicone brush of this mascara was among the first in the mascara industry. It helps apply the mascara easily and evenly without clumping or even shredding. This mascara is easily showing off as you only need one coat for a natural looking lashes, and two coats for a bolder night look. Based on the features, this mascara is a bit pricey compared to other Maybelline mascaras, but the formula is worth the price.
Pros:
- Innovative silicone brush
- Clump free
- Suitable for contact lens wearer
Cons:
- May need several coats for a maximum dramatic effect
13. Maybelline New York The Falsies Push Up Angel Mascara
The unique wing brush and the revolutionary formula help lift and hold your lashes in place for enviable volume. The brush has short bristles to add volume and lift, while the long bristles stretch lashes for a winged look. The formula is also very light so you can definitely wear it comfortably without feeling heavy, perfect for daily use. In addition to that, it is also buildable so you can apply several layers to achieve the desired volume. However, we must say that it’s a little bit pricey but you will get beautiful lashes that look better than falsies with this one.
Pros:
- Lifting and plumping
- Hold curls in place
- Easy to remove
Cons:
- May need several coats to get the desired result
14. Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Rocket Mascara
If you have sensitive eyes that can be easily irritated, then this product is the one to get. It doesn’t add too much length but it can definitely boosts the volume of your lashes wonderfully. You will get darker and thicker lashes without clumps, without a doubt. It is also smudge free once it dries. A little bit pricey but it’s worth a try.
Pros:
- Non irritating
- Instant volume boost
- Washable and easy to remove
Cons:
- The wand is little and you may need some time to work with it without making a mess
15. Maybelline New York Volum’ Express Pumped Up Colossal Mascara
This mascara gives you the separation of lashes you want and a second coat gives you the thickness without looking gloppy. It goes on smooth, and will evenly spread your lashes and make them appear longer. Furthermore, it is buildable and you can also get the maximum effect by building layers without making your lashes clumpy. Moreover, it’s highly affordable and you should definitely give it a try.
Pros:
- Buildable
- Spread smoothly
Cons:
- The thick spoolie making it hard to work for bottom eyelashes
Which Maybelline mascara is best?
The best Maybelline mascara depends on your needs and eyelash goal. For example, the Volum’ Express line does a really good job at adding volume but it doesn’t really give you the noticable length. While the Illegal Length mascara does lengthen your lashes but you need several coats to get more volume. Moreover, you will also need to figure out whether the product contains ingredients that might be not suitable for your eye condition.
Is Maybelline The Falsies a good mascara?
Yes, the Maybelline Falsies is a good mascara and we recommend you to get it if you want to have beautiful looking lashes without having to wear falsies. Due to its name, the Falsies mascara does add noticeable volume, which makes your lashes appear darker and also bolder. It is highly suitable for special occasions or night time look.
What mascara gives you the longest lashes?
There are several mascara from Maybelline that gives you the longest lashes. The Falsies Push Up angel is one of the best Maybelline mascaras that you can get in terms of lengthening your lashes. Another option is the Lash Stiletto, which comes as a good option if you are looking for a mascara that adds length and waterproof as well. Lastly, the Lash Sensational Sky High mascara will also give you a nice long looking mascara effortlessly.
