best pencil eyeliner

15 Best Pencil Eyeliners to Create the Perfect Eye Lines

Whether your makeup look is understated and natural or bold and definitive, you will probably be familiar with eyeliner.

This form of makeup is available in a number of different formats, with liquid liner becoming increasingly popular.

However, liquid liner is a successor to a standard pencil eyeliner that uses kohl in the same way.

With the use of the best pencil eyeliner, you will find it versatile enough to be able to use in a range of different ways that can even rival liquid liners.

Benefits of Good Pencil Eyeliners

Pencil eyeliner can be used to adapt your look, whether you want to blend it to help create a smoky eye or use a bold line. There are a number of other benefits:

  • An ideal way to be able to define the eyes even without any other makeup.
  • Available in a large number of different colors.
  • Versatile enough to be able to use it on different parts of the eye.
  • Available in different styles, such as retractable or that which requires sharpening.
  • Also able to be used to touch-up sparse eyebrows.
  • Available in different formats, such as liquid or kohl.

Using a pencil eyeliner can be a versatile way to help you change your look, allowing you to create a great variation of looks, such as striking or smoky.

It can be used on its own or along with other eye makeup and it is possible to use a line that is as thin or as thick as you like depending on your style or the look that you want to create.

A pencil eyeliner has a range of features that make it an essential part of any makeup kit, including:

  • The use of muted colors can help you to create a subtle look, whereas vibrant colors can help you to create a bold, unique look.
  • It can be used on different parts of the eye in order to create the illusion of the eye being a different shape or size. There are different techniques that can be used to enable this to be achieved.
  • Different types of pencils are available in terms of different factors, such as size and texture.

Finding the Right Option for You

There are a number of factors that should be considered in order to get the best pencil eyeliner that suits you:

  • Eye pencils of varying thicknesses can be useful depending on whether you want a thin or thick line.
  • Some pencils will come with a sharpener so that you do not have to search for one when the tip begins to get dull. Some may come with a lid for easy storage.
  • The softer the pencil is the easier it will be to blend it, such as if you are creating a smoky look.


Instead of trying numerous pencil eyeliner products, you may find the best pencil eyeliner for your style from our list below. We have covered the 15 best pencil eyeliners to create any line style. You can mix and match according to your preferences, from cat and smoky eyes to natural makeup and no-makeup looks. 


Let’s check them out!

Best Pencil Eyeliner

best pencil eyeliner

The L’Oreal Paris Voluminous pencil is the best pencil eyeliner for intense color. Having the tip resembles a regular pencil means that you can draw a thin line or a thicker one by using the side of the tip. It is available in black, brown, and grey, which create a variety of looks for different skin tones.

The CoverGirl Perfect Blend pencil eyeliner is ideal for those who want a classic pencil with the benefit of being able to blend it well. Thanks to its blending tip at the opposite end. Plus, the texture of the pencil is soft enough to make it easy to blend to create a smokey eye.

The Revlon ColorStay pencil is designed for long wear as it provides true color that lasts a long time. Its formula creates an eyeliner that is soft enough to go on well with the first application. It is waterproof, helping you make it smudge-proof to ensure that it does not wear off or fade.

We’d say this eyeliner pencil is perfect for beauty enthusiasts who want to move on from liquid eyeliners. It has a silky and smooth finish of the liquid eyeliner and gives you a smudgy kohl look in a handy pencil form. Plus! The crushed pearl formula allows your eyelids to stay hydrated.

It’s not Fenty if it does not give you plenty! Again, Fenty Beauty presents a wide range of finish for eyeliner pencils that encourages you to create your own styled lines. From metallic and matte to satin and shimmer, they’re all creamy and long-lasting! The 20 shades are there to deliver your creativity in makeup.

Who doesn’t love 4-in-1 products? Because we do! Shiseido released a brand new makeup in the form of an eyeliner product that also acts as kajal, shadow, and brow in one go. Formulated with cease-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof, and tearproof, it guarantees your look to stay on point for 12 hours.

Some worry that pencil eyeliner may be too dry to apply. But with Smashbox Always On Gel, you can glide the lines smoothly on your lids, thanks to the pigment-rich gel texture. Featuring waterproof formula, it also gives you long-lasting, 24-hour gorgeous eyelids to showcase.

The best pencil eyeliners for everlasting beauty lids highlight waterproof and smudge-proof features. These amazing qualities are included in MAC Pro Longwear Eyeliner. It is also transfer-proof that will lock your lines for up to 8 hours. Having a creamy texture and intense color, it is easily applied to your lids for any lines you wish.

Looking outstanding in colorful shades of pencil eyeliners with ABH Norvina Chroma Stix Makeup Pencils. This collection comes in 16 ultra-pigmented vibrant colors that will be great to fully express your artsy side on your eyelids. Besides, it is waterproof and smudge-proof – those qualities you expect from the best pencil eyeliner.

While other pencil eyeliners need sharpening, this one won’t bother you with that. The handy tip swipes perfectly on the lids to give you a silky finish touch that stays put all day. If you wanna have smoky eyes, just go with the smudging tool on the other side to blend the lines away.

Whether glides on the lids or on the inner and upper waterline, Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil will satisfy you with its creamy formula that won’t tug or skip. The bold color displays a long-lasting semi-matte finish that will stand out on any occasion.

Despite being super affordable (under $5!), it doesn’t mean that this pencil eyeliner can’t work well. Instead, it has a creamy, super-rich, pigmented black ink to create a bold accent on your water lines with ease. Also, the transfer-proof and smudge-proof formula provide a 24-hour dazzling look to your eyes.

This Jet Natural Khôl Eyeliner will give you an effortless makeup, no-makeup look with a sultry finish, and dramatic smokey eyes with intense color. Thanks to Jojoba oil, organic shea butter, and marula oil, they are golden ingredients behind those rich shades in this eyeliner.

Deep color with a soft and smooth finish is all about this cartridge-type pencil eyeliner. Thanks to the Argan oil ingredient, it allows you to draw the line smoothly and lightly. It also includes a HydroWax complex to moisturize your lids, making the liner easy to glide on.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

How do you choose pencil eyeliner?

Firstly, make sure you choose pencil eyeliner whose shade matches your eyes. For blue eyes, we recommend gray pencil eyeliner to have a subtle look. Meanwhile, the brown eyes will go great with black, brown, or gray. 


The second one, buy a pencil eyeliner that comes with a sharpener so that you can adjust its sharpness to create either thick or thin looks. 


Lastly, pick one with creamy formula since it will help you glide the eyeliner smoothly on your lids.

What type of eyeliner lasts the longest?

The waterproof liquid eyeliner is sure the ultimate option when it comes to a long-lasting look. 

However, there are numerous gel liner or pencil eyeliner products that will amaze you with their long-lasting formula. For example, Smashbox Always On Gel with its waterproof formula that will last for 24 hours.

Should you get black or brown pencil eyeliner for natural looks?

While people tend to rely on black pencil eyeliner to create bold, defined eyelids, brown pencil eyeliner is the best pencil eyeliner to draw a natural look. The shade is not too intense, yet can fit in any hair or brow color. 

Should you apply mascara or eyeliner first?

No matter what kind of the best pencil eyeliners you have, applying mascara first before eyeliner can be a huge mistake. It can get you in trouble to find the smooth line to glide on your eyeliner. 


Therefore, it is better to set your eyeliner first, then swipe your lashes with mascara to liven up your eyes’ look.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top